Yankee Gems
YANKEE GEMS
NEW ENGLAND ARCHITECTURAL SANCTUARIES
FEATURE A HOME OR RENTAL ($99) ->
<- ALL NEW ENGLAND SANCTUARIES
CIRCA 1920 ISLAND SHINGLE COTTAGE | MONHEGAN, ME

The Carina House on Monhegan Island

A 1920 silver-weathered cedar-shingle cottage with barn-red trim along the dirt lane of Monhegan Island ten miles out to sea.

LIST PRICE & $/SQFT
$649,900 ($406/sf)
EST. ANNUAL TAXES
$2,820/yr ($235/mo)
EST. MONTHLY CARRY
$585/mo (Tax+Heat+Elec)
LIVING AREA & LAND
1,600 Sq Ft · 0.14 Ac
DIRECT BROKERAGE LISTING & FRIDAY DROP

Unlock the Direct Listing for Monhegan, ME

Enter your email to immediately open the official listing on Legacy Properties Sotheby’s International Realty—plus receive our free Friday "5 Most Beautiful Homes in New England" letter (including our Under-$500k historic steals).

ARCHITECTURAL OVERVIEW

The Carina House on Monhegan Island (2 Beds · 2 Baths · 1,600 Sq Ft)

Set directly along the unpaved village lane of Monhegan Island ten miles offshore in the Gulf of Maine, The Carina House is a 1920 silver-weathered cedar-shingle island cottage accented with barn-red window casings and gable trim. Inside, wide-plank hardwood floors, painted structural timber posts, six-over-one sash windows, and an upper-level cathedral studio beneath exposed board-and-batten rafters reflect a century of Maine offshore artist-colony vernacular.

PERIOD CRAFTSMANSHIP, SYSTEMS & THE LAND

Verified Features & Systems Summary

Craftsmanship: Sunlit main parlor with wide-plank hardwood floors, painted timber posts, and six-over-one island windows.

Grounds & Outbuildings: Cathedral-ceilinged upper studio and Monhegan Island’s raw granite Atlantic cliffs steps from the village path.

Systems & Structure: Built in 1920 as The Carina House in Monhegan’s historic car-free fishing and painting community, retaining its unpainted silver cedar shingles and exposed board-and-batten carpentry.

THANKSGIVING & FAMILY XMAS

Thanksgiving At The Harvest Table

Quiet offshore island days after the summer ferry crowds depart, with Atlantic surf booming against Black Head and golden autumn light across the harbor. Spending Christmas week together in Monhegan, ME: 2 bedrooms for visiting family and Cathedral-ceilinged upper studio and Monhegan Island’s raw granite Atlantic cliffs steps from the village path.

EXPERIENCE MONHEGAN, ME FIRST

Want to Spend Thanksgiving or Christmas in Monhegan With the Family Before Buying?

Explore historic cottages, farmhouses, and family vacation rentals available for weekend and holiday stays in Monhegan, ME.

EXPLORE MONHEGAN STAYS ->
CURATED HEIRLOOM GOODS

Bring the New England Porch & Hearth Home

Pieces inspired by this circa 1920 Island Shingle Cottage sanctuary in Monhegan, ME.